| Platinum | Hook and Reel Yonkers |
| Gold | Burkes Restaurant and Bar |
| Gold | Silvio's Italian Restaurant |
| Silver | Yonkers Brewing Company |
| Bronze | Scorpio |
| Top Pick | Carlo's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Heritage Bar & Restaurant |
| Top Pick | La Lanterna |
| Top Pick | Off The Hook Yonkers |
| Top Pick | Rory Dolan's Restaurant & Bar |
| One Pier Steakhouse |
