| Platinum | Silvio's Italian Restaurant |
| Gold | Decosta's Restaurant |
| Silver | Louie & Jonnie's Restaurant |
| Bronze | Pizza Barn |
| Top Pick | Capri Pizza |
| Top Pick | Giovanni's IV Restaurant of Getty Square |
| Top Pick | Midland Avenue Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Pizza |
| Top Pick | Reno's Trattoria |
| Top Pick | Tombolino Ristorante |
