| Platinum | Silvio's Italian Restaurant |
| Gold | A & V Pizzeria |
| Silver | John's Pizza |
| Bronze | Frank Pepe Pizzeria Napoletana |
| Top Pick | Capri Pizza |
| Top Pick | Carlo's Restaurant |
| Top Pick | Catania's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Gino's Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Midland Avenue Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Zero Otto Nove Trattoria |
